QUOTE(artemis @ Oct 31 2007, 02:37 PM)

The list posted with all those products on it - I haven't tried all those by a long shot, but I've tried a lot of them, and I'm not really impressed by any of them. I think it's absurd to claim there are a couple of dozen truly good commercial absinthes in the world. There probably aren't even a half dozen.
I've never claimed, or thought, that there were "a couple of dozen" "truly good absinthes". But I do certainly think there are some, at least a handful. And considering the youth of the industry, a handful isn't bad.
QUOTE(artemis @ Oct 31 2007, 02:37 PM)

It occurs to me that what the hardcore HG cult members are getting at is this: all those barriers about regulations, and labels, etc. etc. come into play AFTER you have a product you want to try and sell.
The restrictions I was referring to, without exception, come into play BEFORE you make the product, or during its production.
QUOTE(artemis @ Oct 31 2007, 02:37 PM)

Maybe what they're saying is that they would like to see research and development that would come up with a really GOOD absinthe, something that can be compared to the old Pernod.
I think there are already some "good absinthes". I don't think anything produced today can be compared to old Pernod. Research and development IS of course proceeding in the commercial sector.
QUOTE(artemis @ Oct 31 2007, 02:37 PM)

This would seem to be a logical position, unless some of those factors actually PREVENT the making of a such a product, or make it so difficult that it isn't worth the effort - if this is the case, it hasn't been explained in a convincing way, at least not that I can understand.
I've never said anything prevents the making of
good absinthe. I've said certain methodologies, certain ways of doing things, which may be possible or desirable in making HG, are either inappropriate, undesirable, or effectively impossible in true commercial production, for various reasons - some regulatory, some legal, some practical. As I said earlier, I've no intention of explaining these any further here online. None of these preclude the making of good absinthe. They simply mean that the techniques and methods appropriate for making 5 litres of absinthe, are not all the same as those appropriate for making 5000 litres of absinthe. I don't find this suprising at all, and I'm amazed that anyone does. My guess is that the same is pretty much true for every type of liquor production, not just absinthe.